Magic Spoon Cereal Review



Value for the Money 95%
Ease of Use 98%
Flavors 96%
Shipping 97%
Subscriptions 98%
Refunds 96%

Advertising Disclosure: Many or all of the companies featured provide compensation to us. These commissions are how we maintain our free service for consumers.  Compensation,  along with hours of in-depth research, determines where & how companies appear on our site.

Advertising Disclosure

Many or all of the companies featured provide compensation to us. These commissions are how we maintain our free service for consumers. Compensation, along with hours of in-depth research, determines where & how companies appear on our site.



Bottom Line

If you’re on a keto diet or need to cut back on sugar, Magic Spoon cereals are great for you. Though the cereal is only available in the US, it comes in multiple flavors that have no sugar and limited carbs along with lots of protein to keep you full.

Product Features

What is Magic Spoon Cereal?

Cereal is a breakfast staple. Whether you’re in a hurry or have a little more time in the morning, the odds are good that you love grabbing a bowl before you head out the door. If you take the time to reach the nutritional information though, you might find yourself shocked at both the recommended serving size and the amount of sugar and calories in a single bowl. Magic Spoon is a newer company that wants to help you enjoy one of your favorite foods without feeling guilty. Known as an alternative cereal brand, this company offers different flavors that will delight your inner child.
Magic Spoon helps you relive your childhood with delicious and healthy cereals.
Greg Sewitz and Gabi Lewis were two friends who loved cereal but hated the way that it made them feel later. Both suffered an afternoon crash caused by the carbs and sugar they had in the morning. Though they looked for better alternatives, all they found were brands that were healthy but didn’t taste good and cereals that tasted great but weren’t healthy. The duo decided to launch a new brand that would remind customers of their favorite breakfast cereals but was better for them. Magic Spoon launched in 2019 with a few flavors and plans to introduce even more flavors. In our Magic Spoon cereal review, you’ll find out the pros and cons of this brand and where to buy it along with the top brands the compete with it.

Magic Spoon Fruity Cereal Review

We wanted to make sure that our Magic Spoon cereal review covered everything you need to know about this breakfast food, which is why we will look at all of the different flavors. One of the most popular is the Fruity cereal. Do you remember Saturday mornings spent sitting in front of the TV with a big bowl of Fruity Pebbles? This flavor will take you right back to those days. It has no sugar and lacks the sugar alcohols, cane syrup and corn syrup that other cereals have. Though the cereal has a delicious fruity flavor, the ingredients do not contain any artificial flavors.
When you pour a bowl, you’ll notice bright colors looking back at you. Don’t worry though because the Fruity flavor lacks artificial colors and dyes. One serving has an impressive 13 grams of protein and just four net carbs. Your serving has no sugar and is free of both filler grains and gluten. Looking at the same serving of Froot Loops, you’ll get 11 more grams of protein to keep you full until lunch along with 28 fewer grams of carbs. If you’re a fan of cereals that have a yummy fruit flavor, you’ll want to order a case of Fruity from Magic Spoon.

How Can You Use Magic Spoon Cereal?

You don’t need to do anything special to enjoy Magic Spoon cereal. Simply pour the cereal into a bowl and add a little milk. While you can use 2% milk or another type of cow’s milk, many customers enjoy this cereal with soy milk and other alternatives. If you’re always in a hurry in the morning and don’t have time to sit down for a meal, grab a handful to snack on as you rush out the door. It’s just as easy to pour a portion into a plastic container to have a snack in your car or later in the day.
There are also tons of recipes and ideas on the internet for using the cereal in a new way. You might use one flavor with some marshmallows and butter to create a twist on cereal treats. Puppy chow is a popular dessert recipe in the Midwest that mixes cereal with powdered sugar and other ingredients. You can easily replace the regular cereal in the recipe with a Magic Spoon cereal. This cereal also serves as a great topping for a bowl of ice cream. Make use of the crumbs left in the bottom of the bag when you sprinkle them over your favorite ice cream.
Magic Spoon is much healthier than other cereals.

Magic Spoon Maple Waffle Cereal Review

Maple Waffle is one of the newer cereal flavors from Magic Spoon, but this flavor gained quite a few fans since its release. Do you love chowing down on a plate of waffles drizzled with maple syrup and whipped cream? While your diet might limit this treat, you can replace those waffles with this cereal and get all of the classic flavors that you love. Designed to compete with Waffle Crisp, this cereal has 13 grams of protein per serving compared to the only three grams found in that other cereal. You’ll also take in less than 27 grams of carbs and get a sweet cereal that has no sugar.
Many customers love that this cereal has an intense maple flavor. While that is the first flavor that you taste, it’s far from the only one. You might pick up on vanilla notes that mimic whipped cream or frosting along with a sweet kick that almost tastes like sprinkles. While a single waffle can have 500 or more calories along with the toppings you choose, one serving of the Maple Waffle cereal has only 100 calories. Even adding milk to your bowl will help you stick to your calorie count.

Where Can You Use Magic Spoon Cereal?

You will likely want to use Magic Spoon cereal at home, but you can enjoy a bowl in any room. Many people do not like eating anywhere except in their kitchen or dining room. If you’re one of those people, don’t worry. Simply keep the cereal box stored in your kitchen or pantry. When you want a bowl, mix it with your favorite milk. Though you may want to eat this cereal in the morning for breakfast, you can also have a bowl for lunch or dinner when you’re not in the mood to cook.
Magic Spoon cereal also serves as a convenient snack in the middle of the day. Do you love sweet treats but hate the way you feel a few hours after eating one? Between sugar and carbs, crashes are common. You might find that you have a hard time focusing on work or that you have no energy and just want to take a nap. Magic Spoon cereals have no sugar and just a small number of carbs along with enough protein to fill up your stomach and keep you full for hours. You can grab a handful of this cereal without feeling guilty about your snack choices.
All of these cereals use natural sweeteners to give you the sweet taste you want without any added sugar.

Magic Spoon Cereal Reviews – Other Flavors

Magic Spoon Peanut Butter

When you close your eyes and think about your favorite cereal, does peanut butter come to mind? If so, try the Peanut Butter flavor. Magic Spoon designed this cereal to compete with Reese’s Puffs, which is a cereal that tastes more like a candy bar than a breakfast dish. This flavor ups the protein to 14 grams per serving and gives you only four net carbs. With Reese’s Puffs, you’ll get 26 net carbs and two grams of protein along with 11 grams of sugar. The rich peanut butter flavor tastes so great that you may want to try using it in other recipes.

Magic Spoon Blueberry

Boo Berry is a popular cereal that is usually only available in the fall. The adorable blue mascot looks right at home on store shelves around Halloween. That cereal has 11 grams of sugar along with 31 net carbs and just two grams of protein per serving. With the Blueberry Magic Spoon cereal, you get the same berry taste and just five net carbs. Thanks to the natural sweeteners, you may find that this version is even sweeter! The serving that you have for breakfast also provides 13 grams of protein to help you feel as if you had a much bigger meal.

Magic Spoon Cookies & Cream

Many people have a hard time starting the day without a sugary kick, which is they reach for chocolate cereals. Magic Spoon offers its Cookies & Cream flavor for chocolate lovers and fans of Oreo O’s. This cereal was popular for many years and then disappeared from stores. At one point, you could only import it from Canada. Though it’s now back in the US, you may have a hard time finding it. Thanks to the Cookies & Cream flavor, you can get the chocolate that you want in the morning and feel good about sticking to your diet. It comes with circular nuggets in both chocolate cookie and vanilla flavors. One serving gives you five net carbs and 13 grams of protein.

Magic Spoon Cinnamon

Do you love Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cereal and all things cinnamon? While cinnamon has some healthy properties, most cereals use flavors that taste like cinnamon without using any real cinnamon. You’ll find cinnamon on the ingredient list in the Magic Spoon cereal. One bowl has only four net carbs and 12 grams of protein compared to the two grams of protein and 38 net carbs found in Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cereal, which also has 11 grams of sugar per serving.

Magic Spoon Frosted Cereal

Frosted Flakes is one of the top cereals in the country. People of all ages know the cereal’s mascot Tony the Tiger. Tony doesn’t tell you that one serving of his cereal has 13 grams of sugar and 32 net carbs. Magic Spoon makes its Frosted Cereal to compete with that brand. Though it has a different look, this cereal has only four net carbs per serving along with no sugar and 13 grams of protein.

Magic Spoon Cocoa

Another option for fans of chocolate cereal is the Cocoa flavor. The little “O’s” that come inside the box are dark brown turn any type of milk a soft brown color that has a slightly chocolate flavor. You’ll even smell the cocoa as soon as you open the box. Designed as a healthy alternative to Cocoa Puffs, one serving has 13 grams of protein and four net carbs. If you had a bowl of Cocoa Puffs, your serving would contain only one gram of protein and 30 net carbs.

Who’s This For?

The founders of Magic Spoon wanted to create an alternative to the traditional cereals found on store shelves. You may not realize just what you eat when you grab one of those other cereals. They can have more than 300 calories before you add milk and come loaded with sugars and carbs. Some cereals even contain more sugar than your favorite desserts do! If you are diabetic or want to try the keto diet, you’ll find that many of your favorite foods are on the forbidden list. Thanks to Magic Spoon, you can enjoy the flavors that you love and grab a bowl of cereal without worrying about your diet.
We recommend these cereals for many shoppers, including:
  • Those who hate the crash they feel later in the day after eating other types of cereal.
  • People looking for a healthy alternative to breakfast cereal that their whole family will love.
  • Customers who don’t mind paying a little more for a healthy cereal.
  • Shoppers in the need of subscription plans that ensure they get their favorite cereals on time.

We’ll talk more about the Magic Spoon subscription plans in our “Where to Buy” section that also shows you where to go to find the top flavors.

You can compare Magic Spoon to the top cereal brands before you buy.

Should You Buy It?

Let’s start with some of the top reasons why Magic Spoon cereal is worth your money. When you compare any of these cereals to those already in your cabinet, you might find yourself shocked at the nutritional information. This cereal has around 13 grams of protein with a small number of carbs and no added sugar. You don’t need to worry about having a sugar crash later in the day or falling off your diet wagon. No matter which flavor you choose, you’ll get a delicious cereal that you can eat any time of the day while sticking to your diet. Magic Spoon gives you the sweet flavors you want through natural sweeteners to cut down on your sugar intake. Some of the other reasons that we recommend this cereal brand include:
  • The cereal has a nice and crunchy texture and leaves behind sweet milk to remind you of your childhood.
  • Thanks to the subscription plans, you’ll save 25% every month and get a minimum of four boxes per shipment.
  • These cereals taste just like the competition and are suitable for kids and adults.
  • You can choose from eight delicious flavors and find new and limited edition flavors.
  • If you can’t have cow’s milk or want to cut back on calories, you can eat the cereal dry or use it with other types of milk.
  • Magic Spoon has a mailing list to help you learn about new flavors and find discounts.
  • More than 25,000 customers rated the brand five stars on the official website.
  • All of the flavors are a healthy alternative to the other cereals you eat.
  • It only takes one business day for most orders to ship.
  • With the 100% satisfaction guarantee, Magic Spoon will refund your money if you’re not happy.
If you love this cereal, make sure you join the Magic Spoon mailing list.

Cons to Consider

As many Magic Spoon cereal reviews only focus on the positives about this brand, we wanted to talk about the cons. When we used the site, we found that we could not open multiple tabs to compare the different flavors and their nutritional information. You can only view one flavor at a time, and you’ll find that the site makes it hard to compare flavors. Another issue is the high cost. Though Magic Spoon claims that you’ll pay less than $10 per box, you can buy other cereals from the grocery store for $5 or less. As each box contains five servings, a case gives you only 20 servings total, which isn’t enough to have one bowl per day. If you share the cereal with others, it will go even faster. Other cons and issues to keep in mind when buying this cereal include:
  • The minimum you can buy is one case, which is four boxes.
  • Magic Spoon does not ship outside of the United States.
  • While the cereal starts out crunchy, it quickly becomes soggy when exposed to milk.
  • Some customers complained about the small size of the boxes and claimed that they only got two servings per box.
  • The Stevia used in the recipe gives the cereal a slightly bitter aftertaste.
  • As soon as the cereal becomes wet, it develops a sticky texture that some dislike.
  • If you buy from Amazon or another retailer, the brand’s guarantee does not apply to your order.
  • A few customers had issues with Magic Spoon refunding them. The official refund policy claims that the brand can deny a refund for any reason.
  • There were many complaints from customers who did not like the flavor. They claimed that it had a powdery flavor or that they didn’t taste anything.
Always check out Magic Spoon cereal reviews on the official site and others before you buy.

Where to Buy

Click here to see just how easily you can order a box of Magic Spoon cereal or sign up for a subscription plan. Magic Spoon makes eight cereal flavors that you can order by the case, which comes with four boxes. If you want to try more than one flavor, feel free to buy a variety pack. Whether you buy four, six or eight boxes, the brand lets you choose your favorite flavors. New customers may want to grab a box of each flavor, but current shoppers may want to stick to their favorites. You also have the chance to look for limited edition flavors such as gingerbread, which is only available in winter. The gingerbread cereal comes in a bundle with two bowls or in packs with four to six boxes.
The cost of a single case is $39, which might seem high. Saving money is easy because Magic Spoon offers a 25% discount when you subscribe. This drops the price to $29.25 and ensures that you get four new boxes the next month. If you want to try a different flavor or grab a variety pack rather than a case of one flavor, just go online and change your order through your account.
Make sure that you keep your eyes peeled for limited edition flavors such as gingerbread every year.

The Competition

The keto diet is one of the top diets around today. It asks that you eat fewer carbs and seriously limit your sugar intake. Many brands make cereals and other snacks that compete with Magic Spoon. We’ll look at those keto and diabetic brands below.

Catalina Crunch

One of the top alternatives to Magic Spoon is Catalina Crunch, which makes delicious snacks that are keto-friendly. We recommend that you start with one of the brand’s variety packs to try multiple flavors. You can choose a pack with four to eight bags and pick which flavors you want to sample from options that include Chocolate Peanut Butter, Chocolate Banana, Honey Graham and Cinnamon Toast. Catalina Crunch also has tons of cookies that combine two crunchy cookies in one flavor with vanilla cream in the center. You’ll find these Oreo alternatives in flavors such as Peanut Butter and Mint Chocolate.

Schoolyard Snacks

When you visit the Schoolyard Snacks website, you have the chance to unlock a special offer to save on your order. Unlike other keto cereals that come in large boxes, these cereals come in small single-serving bags. You can easily mix a bag with milk for breakfast or take a bag with you to have a snack later. Cocoa and Peanut Butter are the top two flavors, but Schoolyard Snacks are also available in Cookies and Cream, Cinnamon Bun and Fruity. This brand also sells bundles that let you pick all of the keto snacks that you want such as cheese puffs and snack bars in different flavors.

Diabetic Kitchen

Both diabetics and those on the keto diet eat many of the same foods, which is why you may want to try Diabetic Kitchen cereals. This brand makes cereals for diabetics who cannot have much sugar. The cereals come in two flavors: Cinnamon Pecan and Almond Butter. Both mix the flavors that you love with granola. These cereals are filling but have few carbs or sugars. You can eat the cereal by the handful as a snack or with milk for breakfast and use them in different recipes. Diabetic Kitchen also has hot chocolate and pancake mixes along with other products for diabetics.

Three Wishes

Three Wishes claims that its cereals are so delicious that they should be forbidden. You can buy a single box for $9.99 or get a bundle that includes six boxes for $39.99. If you buy four or more boxes, the site will take an extra $5 off your order. The Fruity and Cinnamon flavors are among the more popular options because they mimic the classic flavors of kids’ cereal. All of the cereals are kosher and free of peanuts, oat, wheat and other allergens. Though these cereals have more carbs than Magic Spoon cereals do, some customers prefer the flavor of Three Wishes products.

Final Verdict

Finding a cereal that is good for you and tastes great can seem almost impossible. When many people think of healthy cereals, they think of those that use whole grains and other ingredients that never seem to soften in milk and cereals that taste and look like twigs. Magic Cereal wants to change the way you think about cereal with new flavors that taste just the way your childhood favorites did. These cereals contain no more than four carbs per serving and have no added sugar. Each serving has around 13 grams of protein to help you feel as if you just had a big breakfast.
As with other brands, Magic Cereal fans had some complaints. They were unhappy with the high price and that most stores do not stock it. Others didn’t like the refund policy and had a hard time getting their money back. Many customers love this cereal brand so much that they have a subscription and get new boxes each month. They like all of the amazing flavors and how quickly their boxes arrive. If you’re on a keto diet or a diabetic, use our Magic Spoon cereal review to find out all of the benefits of this cereal brand.